Your Wildlife Gardening Gateway

 Wildlife Products that do and don't work

...bringing nature closer to home

By Ken Thompson                                           Reviewed by Steve Head


Garden Centres are now devoting substantial areas of their stores to various wildlife gardening products. While bird food, bird feeders and bird boxes dominate - and the bird feeding industry is thought to be worth £200 million per year - you can buy boxes for bats, hedgehogs, bumblebees, solitary bees - and much more.  Are all these products useful for the wildlife in your garden, or could you be wasting your money.


Wildlife gardening products should work!

Consumers expect the products they buy to work, and will be disappointed if the bug box they buy and set up proves not to attract what they were hoping for.  This disappointment could very easily turn to a rejection of the whole concept of wildlife gardening as a waste of time. This could be particularly unfortunate if the item concerned was bought for a child.  We need more research on wildlife products, but sufficient studies have been made for us to know that while some products are excellent, many are not.  For the full story on garden wildlife products, download the article we have prepared via the green button on the left.  What follows below is a brief summary.

There's a huge range of goodies to buy, but are they worth the expense?

Bird feeders.

These undoubtedly work, in that if you put them in your garden (and keep them filled up) birds will use them, and you will be able to watch them.  Some birds, such as greenfinches prefer the feeders as far from the house as possible, sparrows like them near the house, or by a hedge, giving them cover.  Some species prefer maize or cereal seeds, while finches like oily seeds such as sunflowers.  Birds feed more from feeders in winter, when high calorie foods like fat balls are most appreciated. It is important to keep feeders clean and properly sterilised, or instead of helping your birds, they may be passing on some unpleasant diseases which have appeared recently.

Nest boxes

Lots of studies have shown that songbirds use nesting boxes, and they can help increase their numbers and/or breeding success. It is best if the boxes are faced between north and east, and there is good evidence that boxes made of woodcrete, which is a mix of concrete and sawdust, are preferred by many species, perhaps because they are better insulated than plain wood.  Rather surprisingly, there is little evidence that cleaning out nest boxes annually is necessary, but it is probably worth doing so every two or three years.

Cat deterrents

You can buy ultrasonic devices to keep cats out of your garden, but there is little evidence that they work.  Similarly, fitting deterrents onto the cat’s collar seems no more effective than the old fashioned bell, not that bells are very effective either. One product that does appear to work is the CatBib™ ‘pounce protector’, a neoprene flap hanging from a collar, which warns birds and interferes with pouncing.  The cat loses some dignity, but the device reduces bird catching by 81%, and seems safe, and not to cause distress.

Bat boxes

Evidence suggests that bats prefer dark coloured boxes made of woodcrete, because they are warmer, but occupancy rates are not great, since bats may use different boxes on different occasions and for different purposes.  It is worth persisting though, because older boxes are more likely to be used. 

Bumblebee boxes

UK trials of bumblebee boxes have consistently failed to demonstrate extensive use, or indeed any at all.  Buried boxes, with a long entrance pipe seem to work better than the normal surface boxes offered for sale.  You can even buy boxes with colonies of bumblebees already installed, but there seems little point since bumblebees are common in gardens, and gardens often contain wild nests as well. There is also a danger that these often imported colonies could bring in diseases.

Solitary bee nests

These fascinating insects make simple nests in hollow stems, or holes in wood or stonework, or even excavate nests in soil.  Many sorts of artificial nest are available for a price, and they have been shown to increase bee numbers locally.  You can however make just as good a product yourself, by tying bundles of short sections of bamboo cane together (each blind at one end and open at the other), or by drilling 4 and 6 mm holes into blocks of wood.  You can read more here, and on Marc Carlton's site here.

Home made solitary bee house with drilled wood and bamboo sections.  Some of the holes are in use and have capped ends with larvae developing inside.

Other boxes

If you wish you can invest in boxes sold to encourage ladybirds, lacewings, butterflies, hedgehogs and dormice.  Dormice boxes only work in the very unlikely situation that your garden is next to a nature reserve with a viable colony of dormice. There is little or no evidence that the other boxes work, or that the average garden doesn’t already provide plenty of shelter, especially if you have creepers like ivy on the wall of the house.